vancouver island’s small towns – a review

Jenn and I just got back from spending three nights on Cortes Island. We were really glad to finally get over there and do some exploring, and today I thought it would be fun to do some quick, ruthless reviews of all the small towns on Vancouver Island we have visited over the years.

  • Port Hardy – 3/10. Only spent a half day there so far so all I have is a first impression but it is this: not very interesting, not a lot of spunk or personality. At least there is some actual stuff there though, it’s not a ghost town. Great if you love fishing, which we don’t.
  • Port McNeill – 5/10. Small and ugly but it’s got a tiny bit of charm to it. The giant burls are silly but actually pretty amazing. It’s showing signs of revitalization, what with the new brew pub that is always busy. We ate there and were impressed at how good the food was. There’s a tiny but decent thrift store.
  • Port Alice – 2/10. Sad. Economically depressed. Nothing going on. Not many folks around and the few we saw all looked broke, weird, and/or had substance abuse issues. Too bad because there is lots of cool shit just outside of it in the woods to check out.
  • Sointula – 9/10. Love it. Getting off the ferry here is like stepping back into the 50’s. Great sense of community. Tons of interesting houses. Very cute and adequate grocery store and hardware store. Shockingly decent thrift store. There are way more great hikes than the community lets on but I think they try to downplay them to keep tourists away.
  • Alert Bay – 7/10. Pretty touristy so it’s not my thing but I applaud the indigenous community here for doing such a good job of marketing the island. For such a tiny island there are way more services than other comparably-sized towns. Solid sense of community.
  • Woss – 6/10. Weird and sad but I love Woss. It’s basically a giant trailer park. Lots of cool shit around it in the woods and down the logging roads. The general store is very 70s-ish. Woss is hot as hell in the summer, cold as ice in the winter so we think of it as the Kamloops of the island. We had “dinner” at the pub once and it was incredibly sad and gross and funny, which is basically our wheelhouse. We were the only customers there, seemed like there hadn’t been any other customers for days, when Jenn asked about IPA’s, the lone weird guy working gave her a mystified look and asked “what’s that? We just have Lucky and Budweiser.” The appies we ordered were still frozen in the middle. God bless Woss. I want to do a xmas light tour there ASAP. Woss Lookout is a heck of a hike, and an unsung jewel of the north island.
  • Zeballos – 3/10. Tiny, odd, also sad, but kind of neat. Met some friendly locals there. There is one fantastic view of waterfalls on the road Zeballos, and Little Huson Cave is just off the same road and is probably the single biggest must-see of the north island.
  • Sayward – 4/10. Had an eerie Twin Peaks vibe when we camped there. Found lots of good hiking trails to neat places. Camping in town is neat. You think it would be noisy and shitty but in such a dead little place, it’s actually very quiet and nice. Plus we had a stunning view of marine fog rolling inland and over Sayward Mountain, which was breathtaking. There was an amazing diner here called the Cable House Restaurant but it’s gone now, sadly. It was fucking excellent.
  • Quadra Island – 2/10. It really seems like Quadra should have more going on in terms of community and personality. We have been there a few times and found it dull and largely ugly. Weird place, in a bad way. The north end of it is more interesting with some good hiking and swimming but that’s it.
  • Cortes Island – 5/10. Hornby Island gets all the fame as ground zero for hippies but its become so touristy that I think Cortes actually has this crown now. Lots of militant, extreme, old fashioned hippies. Lots of signs on every hike like “STAY ON THE PATH, EVERY STEP YOU TAKE ON THE MOSS DOES DAMAGE THAT WILL TAKE DECADES TO HEAL.” There aren’t a ton of people on the island and they are very spread out so it doesn’t feel like a strong community but I get the feeling it is. We really enjoyed Easter Bluff, Manson’s Landing, and Peter’s Orchard. The free store was actually quite decent too.
  • Campbell River – 6/10. I know, CR is too big to qualify for this ‘small town’ list but I like it too much not to include it, and too many south islanders don’t know shit about it. There is so much great camping and hiking nearby, and some amazing eating too — The Ideal Cafe and Perk’s Donuts are two of my fave stops to make when passing through. But also, I like the old, shitty, working class town/redneck vibe of CR. It reminds me of what Duncan felt like when I was a kid.
  • Gold River – 3/10. Not much here unless you are a retiree who loves to fish but somehow, it still seems like a pretty healthy little community. The grocery store closed down a number of years ago so you have to drive to Campbell River for pretty much anything which is nuts to me but despite this, the town still seems to be doing ok. I love that it’s right in the middle of Strathcona Park. If you were young and healthy enough and able to work from home in Gold River, you could do so much exploring in Strathcona, which would be pretty cool.
  • Tahsis – 1/10. Tahsis is my least favourite of all the small towns we’ve visited on the island. It’s poor and ugly and that’s about it. I’ve heard some young people have started moving there or at least buying vacation property there so maybe it’s changed since Jenn and I went there several years ago but when I went, it was primarily comprised of poor white trash on social assistance living in rotten houses. The museum was a portable building with nothing from the last 35 years because the town has done nothing but languish since the mill closed. There is a cave just off the road on the drive to Tahsis and that was the only neat thing I remember from our trip there.
  • Denman Island – 3/10. I’m definitely uninformed about Denman, I really only passed through it on the way to Hornby, and I haven’t been to Hornby in 10 years so take my rating with a grain of salt. I remember thinking it seemed boring.
  • Hornby Island – 6/10. It’s too touristy but there is still has some magic to it. I like the community center movie night, I like the free store, there are some lovely beaches, I liked how remote Ford Cove felt. Helliwell is cool too. Strong sense of community.
  • Texada Island – 3/10. Texada is interesting because it’s a gulf island so you expect it to have hippie vibes but it was largely industry-based, and even though those industries are shut down now, the asshole rednecks are still there. Not a very friendly place. We found one cool hike. Oh, the museum there was actually really well done, surprisingly. The abandoned quarries with their aquamarine-coloured water were insanely beautiful.
  • Power River – 7/10. Yeah it’s on the mainland. Sue me. We really liked Powell River. Townsite, aka the old section, has so many cool heritage buildings. The new section isn’t very special but it has everything you could need in a mid-sized town. Lots of neat surrounding areas too, like Cranberry. Magpie’s Diner was excellent, and very popular. Lots of great camping and hiking around Powell River.
  • Port Alberni – 8/10. I think Port Alberni is generally underrated. The thrift stores there are fantastic. I LOVE the J&L Diner. I haven’t been to The Donut Shop but have heard high praise of it from numerous people. Port Alberni is doing a great job of riding the line between ‘total shit hole’ and ‘revitalized/gentrified community,’ it’s got the best aspects of both of those things. If only it weren’t so fucking hot there in the summer.
  • Tofino – 2/10. Boring. Too much surfer bro/hipster culture there. Too many tourists too. Some great restaurants though.
  • Ucluelet – 3/10. Tofino’s less touristy sibling. Still a lot of surfer bro’s and hipsters but not as many, and not as many tourists. There are a few cool shops and bakeries. There is one nice walk. But if you don’t surf, there’s still not much here for you, and I don’t surf.
  • Lake Cowichan/Mesachie Lake/Honeymoon Bay – 7/10. This trio is actually pretty cool. They also strike a good balance between being economical depressed/sad and funny but not too much so. We got deep fried ice cream in Lake Cow the last time we went camping out that way and it was fucking awesome. There is some great camping past Honeymoon Bay, fantastic spelunking (that’s caving for the uninitiated) and a crashed WWII plane up on a mountain.

I know there are others, like Port Renfrew and Cumberland, but I’ve only spent a few minutes in those places so I’m even less qualified to comment on them than I am these above ones. But heck, looking back at this list I’m pretty impressed with myself. I’m glad I’ve gotten out and checked out so many places around here.